基于同行评审视角的地理学论文写作与投稿

doi:10.11821/dlxb201709015

摘要/Abstract

摘要：

地理学论文是地理学研究成果的重要体现形式，也是地理科技信息传递和存储的重要载体。如何将科研成果以论文形式较快地发表于影响力较大的科技期刊，让科研成果得到社会认可，是地理工作者最关心的问题。在分析地理学论文的潜在期刊类型及目标期刊的选择原则基础上，指出具有统一在线采编系统的期刊集群将成为发展趋势并极大地方便作者投稿。在分析了当前学术期刊同行评审形式及同行评审专家选择原则的基础上，从同行评审视角对论文写作过程中的选题创新性、研究方法、摘要、引言、讨论与结论、地理图表、参考文献等内容进行了探讨。最后，在分析同行审稿意见类型的基础上，将同行评审意见概括为修稿或退稿2种类型，针对性地提出作者应如何根据审稿意见进行论文修改并对审稿意见进行回复；对于退稿意见，也应该认真分析同行专家的评审意见，找出文章的问题所在，进行文章研究方法、研究内容等方面的全面修改或完善，在确定解决相关问题后再重新投稿。地理学论文是地理学研究成果的重要体现形式，也是地理科技信息传递和存储的重要载体。如何将科研成果以论文形式较快地发表于影响力较大的科技期刊，让科研成果得到社会认可，是地理工作者最关心的问题。在分析地理学论文的潜在期刊类型及目标期刊的选择原则基础上，指出具有统一在线采编系统的期刊集群将成为发展趋势并极大地方便作者投稿。在分析了当前学术期刊同行评审形式及同行评审专家选择原则的基础上，从同行评审视角对论文写作过程中的选题创新性、研究方法、摘要、引言、讨论与结论、地理图表、参考文献等内容进行了探讨。最后，在分析同行审稿意见类型的基础上，将同行评审意见概括为修稿或退稿2种类型，针对性地提出作者应如何根据审稿意见进行论文修改并对审稿意见进行回复；对于退稿意见，也应该认真分析同行专家的评审意见，找出文章的问题所在，进行文章研究方法、研究内容等方面的全面修改或完善，在确定解决相关问题后再重新投稿。

关键词: 同行评审, 地理学, 论文写作, 投稿

Abstract:

A geography paper is an important manifestation of geographical achievements as well as a significant carrier of information transmission and storage for geographical science and technology. How to publish scientific papers in a more influential scientific and technical journal so that the achievements can be recognized by the community, is a major concern of geographers. In this paper, we analyzed the types of potential journals and the choice principles of target journals and pointed out that the journal groups with unified online editing system had become the trends because they facilitated the paper submission. After that, we investigated current peer review forms and the choice rules of peer reviewers, and explored several key points of paper writing, including the innovation, research methods, abstract, introduction, discussion and conclusion, figures and tables and references. Finally, we analyzed comment types of peer reviews and identified them into two main types: revision and rejection. For a paper requiring revision, we suggested that the authors should carefully revise the paper and respond to the comments from reviewers. For a paper rejected, the authors should make clear the problems, make a comprehensive modification or improvement in the research methods, research contents and so on, and resubmit the paper.

Key words: peer review, geography, paper writing, contribution

李加林, 何书金, 朱晓华. 基于同行评审视角的地理学论文写作与投稿[J]. 地理学报, 2017, 72(9): 1717-1728.

Jialin LI, Shujin HE, Xiaohua ZHU. Writing and contribution of geography papers from the perspective of peer review[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017, 72(9): 1717-1728.

参考文献 32

[1]	Acta Geographica Sinica..
	[《地理学报》编辑部.]
[2]	Geographical Research..
	[《地理研究》编辑部.]
[3]	Scientia Geographica Sinica., 2014-06-20.
	[《地理科学》编辑部, 2014-06-20.]
[4]	Zhu Xiaohua, He Shujin, Yuan Lihua.The development and practice of the cluster service platform of Chinese geography and resources periodicals ,Acta Geographica Sinica, 2017, 72(5): 918-941. doi: 10.11821/dlxb201705012
	[朱晓华, 何书金, 袁丽华. 中国地理与资源期刊集群化服务平台的发展与实践. 地理学报, 2017, 72(5): 918-941.] doi: 10.11821/dlxb201705012
[5]	Liu Hong, Hu Xinhe.The development, methods and challenges of peer review in academic journals. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2005, 16(5): 605-608.
	[刘红, 胡新和. 学术期刊同行评审的发展、方式及挑战. 中国科技期刊研究, 2005, 16(5): 605-608.]
[6]	Li Junji, Ruan Aiping, Wang Qinping.The development of peer review system of academic journals under the condition of multi-media fusion. Acta Editologica, 2016, 28(6): 539-543. doi: 10.16811/j.cnki.1001-4314.2016.06.008
	[李军纪, 阮爱萍, 王沁萍. 多媒介融合出版条件下学术期刊同行评审制度的发展. 编辑学报, 2016, 28(6): 539-543.] doi: 10.16811/j.cnki.1001-4314.2016.06.008
[7]	Ren Shengli, Wang Jiuli.The impact of reviewers' selection on peer review results in peer review: A case study of "Progress in Natural Science". Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2006, 17(5): 722-725. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-7143.2006.05.010
	[任胜利, 王久丽. 同行评议中审稿人遴选方式对审稿结果的影响: 以《自然科学进展》为例. 中国科技期刊研究, 2006, 17(5): 722-725.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-7143.2006.05.010
[8]	Association of Learned and Professional Society. Current practice in peer review. Results of A survey Conducted during Oct/Nov 2000. Worthing, UK: Association of Learned and Professional Society Publishers, 2000.
[9]	Xu Shuling, Fang Wei.Peer review for scholarly papers: Past, present, and future. Acta Editologica, 2016, 28(6): 535-538.
	[徐书令, 房威. 学术论文同行评审: 过去·现状·未来. 编辑学报, 2016, 28(6): 535-538.]
[10]	Liu Mianling, Wang Jianhua.Choosing reviewers: How to improve the quality of drafting of scientific papers. Acta Editologica, 2003, 15(1): 71-73. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-3884.2003.01.023
	[刘棉玲, 王建华. 选择审稿人: 如何提高科技论文的审稿质量. 编辑学刊, 2003, 15(1): 71-73.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1007-3884.2003.01.023
[11]	Du Kaixi, Jiang Mingshan.A peer review of journal articles and opening reports. Journal of Dialectics of Nature, 1988, 10(4): 25-32, 80.
	[杜开昔, 姜明山. 对期刊文章和开题报告的同行评审. 自然辩证法通讯, 1988, 10(4): 25-32, 80.]
[12]	Yao Lufeng, He Jinshu, Zhao Xin.Requirements for the writing of mathematical models in geography papers. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2007, 62(5): 555-560. doi: 10.3321/j.issn:0375-5444.2007.05.012
	[姚鲁烽, 何书金, 赵歆. 地理学论文的数学模型写作要求. 地理学报, 2007, 62(5): 555-560.] doi: 10.3321/j.issn:0375-5444.2007.05.012
[13]	Han Longfei, Xu Youpeng, Yang Liu, et al.Temporal and spatial change of stream structure in Yangtze River Delta and its driving forces during 1960s-2010s. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015, 70(5): 819-827. doi: 10.11821/dlxb201505012
	[韩龙飞, 许有鹏, 杨柳, 等. 近50年长三角地区水系时空变化及其驱动机制. 地理学报, 2015, 70(5): 819-827.] doi: 10.11821/dlxb201505012
[14]	Li Jialin, Liu Chuang, Zhang Dianfa, et al.The influence of land use change on soil quality of soil genetic layers: A case study on the coastal plain of South Hangzhou Bay. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2006, 61(4): 378-388. doi: 10.3321/j.issn:0375-5444.2006.04.005
	[李加林, 刘闯, 张殿发, 等. 土地利用变化对土壤发生层质量演化的影响: 以杭州湾南岸滨海平原为例. 地理学报, 2006, 61(4): 378-388.] doi: 10.3321/j.issn:0375-5444.2006.04.005
[15]	Ma Renfeng, Wang Mei, Zhang Wenzhong, et al.Residents' perceptions of the impact on urban human settlements from petrochemical industry cluster in port area: Case study of Zhenhai District. Geographical Research, 2015, 34(4): 729-739. doi: 10.11821/dlyj201504011
	[马仁锋, 王美, 张文忠, 等. 临港石化集聚对城镇人居环境影响的居民感知: 宁波镇海案例. 地理研究, 2015, 34(4): 729-739.] doi: 10.11821/dlyj201504011
[16]	Li Jialin, Xu Jiqin, Li Weifang, et al.Spatio-temporal characteristics of urbanization area growth in the Yangtze River Delta. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2007, 62(4): 437-447. doi: 10.3321/j.issn:0375-5444.2007.04.010
	[李加林, 许继琴, 李伟芳, 等. 长江三角洲地区城市用地增长的时空特征分析. 地理学报, 2007, 62(4): 437-447.] doi: 10.3321/j.issn:0375-5444.2007.04.010
[17]	Du Hongping,WangYuandi. The scientific paradigm of the reference citation in academic papers. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2017, 28(1): 18-23.
	[杜红平, 王元地. 学术论文参考文献引用的科学化范式研究. 中国科技期刊研究,2017, 28(1):18-23.]
[18]	Zhang Yu, GeJianping, Su Lei, et al. How to utilize the review comments effectively to process manuscripts. Acta Editologica, 2016, 28(1): 47-49. doi: 10.16811/j.cnki.1001-4314.2016.01.017
	[张玉, 葛建平, 苏磊, 等. 如何有效利用专家审稿意见处理稿件. 编辑学报, 2016, 28(1): 47-49.] doi: 10.16811/j.cnki.1001-4314.2016.01.017
[19]	Zhou Minxi, Liu Yongxue, Li Manchun, et al.Geomorphologic information extraction for multi-objective coral islands from remotely sensed imagery: A case study for Yongle Atoll, South China Sea. Geographical Research, 2015, 34(4):677-690.
	[周旻曦, 刘永学, 李满春, 等. 多目标珊瑚岛礁地貌遥感信息提取方法: 以西沙永乐环礁为例. 地理研究,2015, 34(4): 677-690.]
[20]	GrantA M, Pollock T G. From the editors, publishing in AMJ-Part3: Setting the hook. Academy of Management Journal, 2011, 54(5): 873-879. doi: 10.5465/amj.2011.4000
[21]	Shao Jing'an, Zhang Shichao, Wei Chaofu. Remote sensing analysis of land use change in the Three Gorges Reservoir area, based on the construction phase of large-scale water conservancy project. Geographical Research, 2013, 32(12):2189-2203. doi: 10.11821/dlyj201312002
	[邵景安, 张仕超, 魏朝富. 基于大型水利工程建设阶段的三峡库区土地利用变化遥感分析. 地理研究,2013, 32(12): 2189-2203.] doi: 10.11821/dlyj201312002
[22]	Shen Yongming, Wang Yanfang, Chen Shoujun, et al.The temporal and spatial distributions of the macrobenthos in Spartina alterniflora salt marsh. Geographical Research, 2013, 32(4): 638-644. doi: 10.11821/yj2013040006
	[沈永明, 王艳芳, 陈寿军, 等. 互花米草盐沼湿地大型底栖动物时空分布特征. 地理研究, 2013, 32(4): 638-644.] doi: 10.11821/yj2013040006
[23]	Chang Simin.Types of peer review comments and principles of accepting or not. Acta Editologica, 2009, 21(3): 205-206.
	[常思敏. 审稿意见的类型及编辑的取舍原则. 编辑学报, 2009, 21(3): 205-206.]
[24]	Ma Zhifeng.Reference citation and the factors influencing the citation. Acta Editologica, 2009, 21(1): 23-25.
	[马智峰. 参考文献的引用及影响引用的因素分析. 编辑学报, 2009, 21(1): 23-25.]
[25]	Tao Fan.Discrimination on citing principles of references. Acta Editologica, 2006, 18(4): 252-254. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-4314.2006.04.005
	[陶范. 参考文献引用原则辨析. 编辑学报, 2006, 18(4): 252-254.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-4314.2006.04.005
[26]	Zhu Pingsheng, Feng Xiaoyun.The making and using charts in scientific papers. Journal of Marine Meteorology, 2006, 26(1): 47-52. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-0582.2006.01.016
	[朱平盛, 冯晓云. 科技论文中图表的制作与使用. 山东气象学报, 2006, 26(1): 47-52.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1005-0582.2006.01.016
[27]	Wang Ping.Some points on the recording principles for references in SCI-tech periodicals. Acta Editologica, 2004, 16(1): 35-36. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-4314.2004.01.016
	[王平. 参考文献引用原则的探讨. 编辑学报, 2004, 16(1): 35-36.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-4314.2004.01.016
[28]	Land Administration Bureau of the Tibet Autonomous Region. Land Use in the Tibet Autonomous Region. Beijing: Science Press, 1992.
	[西藏自治区土地管理局. 西藏自治区土地利用. 北京: 科学出版社, 1992.]
[29]	Xiang Zheng, Wang Yanping, Yan Xue, et al.Principles of reference recording in scientific papers and their editing methods. Acta Editologica, 2003, 15(2): 108-109. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-4314.2003.02.014
	[向政, 王燕萍, 闫雪, 等. 科技论文参考文献的著录原则及编辑方法. 编辑学报,2003, 15(2): 108-109.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-4314.2003.02.014
[30]	Zhao Huanting, Wen Xiaosheng, Sun Zongxun, et al.Natural characteristics of coral reefs in Nansha Islands, Acta Oceanologica Sinica, 1996, 18(5):61-70.
	[赵焕庭, 温孝胜, 孙宗勋, 等. 南沙群岛珊瑚礁自然特征. 海洋学报, 1996, 18(5): 61-70.]
[31]	Li Xiaoling.Review and prospect of geographical academic journals in China. Tropical Geography, 2009, 29(2): 199-204. doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-5221.2009.02.019
	[李小玲. 我国地理学术期刊发展回顾与展望. 热带地理, 2009, 29(2): 199-204.] doi: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-5221.2009.02.019
[32]	Li Xiaoling.Comparison of the mainstream geographical journals between the West and China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014, 69(7): 1025-1038.
	[李小玲. 中西方主流地理期刊发展对比. 地理学报, 2014, 69(7): 1025-1038.]