地理学报 ›› 2016, Vol. 71 ›› Issue (4): 680-692.doi: 10.11821/dlxb201604011

• • 上一篇    下一篇

SCI/SSCI期刊与中文权威核心期刊论文的学术价值评价——基于地理工作者的感知分析

朱晓华1, 何书金1, 王岱1, 孙枫2, 汪德根2   

  1. 1. 中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所,北京100101;
    2. 苏州大学旅游系,苏州215123
  • 收稿日期:2015-12-01 发布日期:2020-05-22
  • 作者简介:朱晓华(1972-), 男, 安徽宣城人, 博士, 副研究员, 中国地理学会会员(S110008284M), 主要从事综合自然学研究, 目前担任《地理研究》专职副主编、编辑部主任。E-mail: zhuxh@igsnrr.ac.cn
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金项目(41471125)

Evaluation of academic value of papers in SCI/SSCI and Chinese core journals:A geographer perspective

ZHU Xiaohua1, HE Shujin1, WANG Dai1, SUN Feng2, WANG Degen2   

  1. 1. Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research, CAS, Beijing 100101, China;
    2. Tourism Department of Soochow University, Suzhou 215123, Jiangsu, China
  • Received:2015-12-01 Published:2020-05-22
  • Supported by:
    National Natural Science Foundation of China, No.41471125]

摘要: 进入信息全球化时代,SCI/SSCI 论文越来越成为中国各高校及科研院所等单位衡量其基础研究实力的评价标准,甚至出现“唯‘SCI/SSCI’论”的现象,中文权威核心期刊论文的学术价值评定和认可度则相应降低,这在一定程度上对中文权威核心期刊的发展造成了不小的冲击。基于探索性因子分析,构建了中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的结构方程假设模型,以地理科学工作者为例,通过验证性因子分析,实证研究了地理工作者对中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的影响因素。结果显示:① 学术成果影响力是影响中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的关键因素,科研评价和学术地位认定政策及学术影响力评价是影响中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的重要因素;② 学术成果影响力对认可度影响程度最大,其影响路径系数为0.52,其次为学术影响力评价,路径系数为0.25,科研评价和学术地位认定政策影响程度较小;③ 学术成果影响力和学术影响力评价与认可度表现为正相关关系,而科研评价和学术地位认定政策与认可度之间则表现为负相关关系。最后,提出了增强科研工作者对中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的相关对策,以期提升作者发表中文权威核心期刊论文的意愿度,来促进中文权威核心期刊的持续发展。

关键词: SCI/SSCI 期刊, 中文权威核心期刊, 论文学术价值, 认可度, 地理工作者

Abstract: With the development of informatization and globalization, SCI/SSCI papers have increasingly been the evaluation criteria for Chinese universities and other research institutes to measure their basic research strength. Moreover, with the emergence of the phenomenon that just focus on SCI/SSCI papers, the academic value assessment and accreditation of papers in Chinese core journals has been reduced accordingly. In a certain extent, this causes a shock to the development of Chinese core journals. Based on the exploratory factor analysis, the paper constructs the structural equation model of the recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals. By taking the geographer as an example, through the confirmatory factor analysis, the paper studies on the influence factors of the recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals. The results showed: (1) Influence of academic achievement is the key factor of recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals, as well as policy of research evaluation and academic status and academic influence evaluation are important ones; (2) Influence of academic achievement has the greatest influence on recognition with the path coefficient of 0.52, followed by academic influence evaluation with the path coefficient of 0.25. Policy of research evaluation and academic status has relatively less influence; (3) Influence of academic achievement and academic influence evaluation show positive correlations with recognition, while policy of research evaluation and academic status shows a negative one. At last, the paper puts forward some countermeasures to enhance geographers' recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals, in order to promote researchers' willingness to publish high quality Chinese papers and boost the development of Chinese core journals.

Key words: SCI/SSCI, Chinese core journal, academic value, recognition, geographer