SCI/SSCI期刊与中文权威核心期刊论文的学术价值评价——基于地理工作者的感知分析

doi:10.11821/dlxb201604011

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 进入信息全球化时代，SCI/SSCI 论文越来越成为中国各高校及科研院所等单位衡量其基础研究实力的评价标准，甚至出现“唯‘SCI/SSCI’论”的现象，中文权威核心期刊论文的学术价值评定和认可度则相应降低，这在一定程度上对中文权威核心期刊的发展造成了不小的冲击。基于探索性因子分析，构建了中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的结构方程假设模型，以地理科学工作者为例，通过验证性因子分析，实证研究了地理工作者对中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的影响因素。结果显示：① 学术成果影响力是影响中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的关键因素，科研评价和学术地位认定政策及学术影响力评价是影响中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的重要因素；② 学术成果影响力对认可度影响程度最大，其影响路径系数为0.52，其次为学术影响力评价，路径系数为0.25，科研评价和学术地位认定政策影响程度较小；③ 学术成果影响力和学术影响力评价与认可度表现为正相关关系，而科研评价和学术地位认定政策与认可度之间则表现为负相关关系。最后，提出了增强科研工作者对中文权威核心期刊论文学术价值认可度的相关对策，以期提升作者发表中文权威核心期刊论文的意愿度，来促进中文权威核心期刊的持续发展。

关键词: SCI/SSCI 期刊, 中文权威核心期刊, 论文学术价值, 认可度, 地理工作者

Abstract: With the development of informatization and globalization, SCI/SSCI papers have increasingly been the evaluation criteria for Chinese universities and other research institutes to measure their basic research strength. Moreover, with the emergence of the phenomenon that just focus on SCI/SSCI papers, the academic value assessment and accreditation of papers in Chinese core journals has been reduced accordingly. In a certain extent, this causes a shock to the development of Chinese core journals. Based on the exploratory factor analysis, the paper constructs the structural equation model of the recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals. By taking the geographer as an example, through the confirmatory factor analysis, the paper studies on the influence factors of the recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals. The results showed: (1) Influence of academic achievement is the key factor of recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals, as well as policy of research evaluation and academic status and academic influence evaluation are important ones; (2) Influence of academic achievement has the greatest influence on recognition with the path coefficient of 0.52, followed by academic influence evaluation with the path coefficient of 0.25. Policy of research evaluation and academic status has relatively less influence; (3) Influence of academic achievement and academic influence evaluation show positive correlations with recognition, while policy of research evaluation and academic status shows a negative one. At last, the paper puts forward some countermeasures to enhance geographers' recognition of academic value of papers in Chinese core journals, in order to promote researchers' willingness to publish high quality Chinese papers and boost the development of Chinese core journals.

Key words: SCI/SSCI, Chinese core journal, academic value, recognition, geographer

朱晓华, 何书金, 王岱, 孙枫, 汪德根. SCI/SSCI期刊与中文权威核心期刊论文的学术价值评价——基于地理工作者的感知分析[J]. 地理学报, 2016, 71(4): 680-692.

ZHU Xiaohua, HE Shujin, WANG Dai, SUN Feng, WANG Degen. Evaluation of academic value of papers in SCI/SSCI and Chinese core journals:A geographer perspective[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2016, 71(4): 680-692.

参考文献

[1] Jia Zhiyun. Academic Quality of Chinese Journals of Science and Technology Reflects that Management Policies Need Improving: A Statistical Analysis Based on Annual Variations of Academic Influence of Chinese Journals Covered by SCI. Bulletin of Chinese Academy of Sciences, 2010, 25(4): 448-453. [贾志云. 中国科技期刊的学术质量折射出管理政策需要改善. 中国科学院院刊, 2010, 25(4): 448-453.]
[2] Du Xueliang, Han Bing. An analysis of international academic influence of universities. Journal of Beijing Information Science and Technology University, 2010, 25(12): 25-28. [杜学亮, 韩冰. 高校国际学术影响力指标浅析: 从中国政法大学社科统计年报看学校国际学术影响力. 北京信息科技大学学报, 2010, 25(12): 25-28.]
[3] Wang Dan. Introduction on SCI, SSCI journals of human geography and suggestion on paper writing and submission. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2010, 30(4): 636-642. [王丹. SCI、SSCI 收录人文地理学期刊介绍及投稿建议. 地理科学, 2010, 30(4): 636-642.]
[4] Ministry of Science and Technology. National "12th Five-Year" scientific and technological development plan.http://www.most.gov.cn/mostinfo/xinxifenlei/gjkjgh/201107/t20110713_88230_2.htm, 2011-07-04. [科学技术部. 国家“十二五”科学和技术发展规划. http://www.most.gov.cn/mostinfo/xinxifenlei/gjkjgh/201107/t20110713_88230_2.htm, 2011-07-04.]
[5] Luo Jingjing. A review of Chinese scholars' papers published in international academic journals. Manager' Journal, 2014(16): 336. [骆京景. 中国学者在国际学术期刊上论文发表情况的研究综述. 经营管理者, 2014(16): 336.]
[6] Yuan Xilin, Lu Mei, Liu Li. A Probe into Institutional Repository- based International Academic Papers Management Pattern. Information and Documentation Services, 2014, 20(2): 87-91. [袁曦临, 陆美, 刘利. 基于机构知识库的国际学术论文管理模式探讨. 情报资料工作, 2014, 20(2): 87-91.]
[7] Fu Xiaoxia, You Suning, Li Guicun. Influence of journals indexed by SCI on Chinese journals based on the published articles from 2000 to 2009. Acta Editologica, 2011, 23(3): 209-214. [付晓霞, 游苏宁, 李贵存. 从2000-2009 年我国在SCI收录期刊发表的论文数据看SCI对我国科技期刊的影响. 编辑学报, 2011, 23(3): 209-214.]
[8] Wang Degen, ChenTian, Wang Jinlian, et al. Comparison of Domestic and Overseas Tourism Research from 1980 to2009. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2011, 66(4): 535-548. [汪德根, 陈田, 王金莲, 等. 1980-2009 年国内外旅游研究比较.地理学报, 2011, 66(4): 535-548.]
[9] Hicks D,Wouters P,Waltman L, et al. The Leiden Manifesto for research metrics. Nature, 2015, 520: 429-431.
[10] China Association for Science and Technology. Some opinions on the function of scientific journals in academic evaluation. http://www.cast.org.cn/n35081/n35488/16753578.html. [中国科学技术协会. 关于准确把握科技期刊在学术评价中作用的若干意见. http://www.cast.org.cn/n35081/n35488/16753578.html.]
[11] Wang Xianwen, Liu Zewen, Luan Chunjuan. Analysis of SSCI human geography journals. Acta Geographica Sinica,2009, 64(2): 243-252. [王贤文, 刘则渊, 栾春娟. SSCI 数据库中的人文地理学期刊分析. 地理学报, 2009, 64(2): 243-252.]
[12] Liu Yungang. An introduction to Western geographical publications outside SCI. Human Geography, 2010, 24(5): 31-35. [刘云刚. 地理学期刊与地理学的传统: 西方主要国家地理学期刊评价. 人文地理, 2010, 24(5): 31-35.]
[13] Shao Yafen. Reserch on the international discourse power in economics- based on the analysis of SSCI journals and editorial gatekeepers [D]. Shanghai: Shanghai Jiao Tong University, 2011. [邵娅芬. 经济学科的国际学术话语权研究:基于SSCI 源期刊编委的分析[D]. 上海: 上海交通大学, 2011.]
[14] Hong Haijuan, Zhu Li. Measures to improve the numbers of papers indexed by the three major international retrieval system. Zhejiang University Library and Information Work, 2007(6): 14-17. [洪海娟, 朱莉. 提高学术论文被国际三大检索系统收录引用的建议. 浙江高校图书情报工作, 2007(6): 14-17.]
[15] Ye Min. Countermeasures to improve the numbers of papers indexed by SCI, EI and ISTP. Journal of Nanjing University of Science and Technology (Social Science Edition), 2009, 22(3): 106-110. [叶敏. 提高高校科技论文SCI、EI、ISTP收录数的对策. 南京理工大学学报(社会科学版), 2009, 22(3): 106-110.]
[16] Wang Yan, Li Hongjian. An introduction to the source journals of physical geography and related fields catalogued by SCI. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2005, 60(6): 1029-1040. [王彦, 李宏建. 地理学及部分相关学科SCI 收录期刊介绍. 地理学报, 2005, 60(6): 1029-1040.]
[17] Zhou Wuzong. My experience in publishing papers in academic periodicals. Science Foundation of China, 1999, 12(3):178-181. [周午纵. 我在国际学术期刊发表论文的几点体会. 中国科学基金, 1999, 12(3): 178-181.]
[18] Li Shiyong. The phenomenon and causes of utilitarian about academic research in China. Journal of Hunan University of Science Technology (Social Science Edition), 2011, 14(4): 98-101. [李石勇. 我国高校学术研究功利化之表现及其治理探析. 湖南科技大学学报(社会科学版), 2011, 14(4): 98-101.]
[19] Huang Xiaolin, Chen Yin. The academic influence of library in recent years from CSSCI. State Library Journal, 2013, 14(1): 75-79. [黄筱玲, 陈瑛. 从CSSCI看《图书馆》近年来的学术影响力. 国家图书馆学刊, 2013, 14(1): 75-79.]
[20] Zhang Tieming, Yan Shuai, Tong Jianguo. Ideas to promote academic influence of Chinese sci- tech. Acta Editologic,2010, 22(2): 99-102. [张铁明, 颜帅, 佟建国. 关于提高我国科技期刊学术影响力的思考. 编辑学报, 2010, 22(2): 99-102.]
[21] Wang Ping, Zhen Zhiyong. Wen Zeyu. Ways of improving the influence of college academic journals. Science-Technology and Management, 2010, 12(5): 137-140. [王萍, 甄志勇, 温泽宇. 高校学报学术影响力提高的方法和措施. 科技与管理, 2010, 12(5): 137-140.]
[22] Han Weidong, Xue Qinfen, Wang Lizhen. Mining high cited papers is conducive to improve the academic influence of scientific and Technological Journals, Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2010, 21(4): 514-518. [韩维栋, 薛秦芬, 王丽珍. 挖掘高被引论文有利于提高科技期刊的学术影响力. 中国科技期刊研究, 2010, 21(4): 514-518.]
[23] Li Hua, Li Zheng, Gu Caidong, et al. Weights analysis of the measurement index in the evaluation of the academic influence of science and Technology Journals. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2010, 21(6): 817-819. [李华, 李政, 顾才东, 等. 文献计量指标在科技期刊学术影响力评价中权重分析. 中国科技期刊研究, 2010, 21(6): 817-819.]
[24] Wang Zelong. Academic influence of university journals. Journal of Southwest University for Nationalities (Humanities and Social Sciences), 2012, 10(3): 229-234. [王泽龙. 高校学报学术影响力分析——基于2001-2009 年CSSCI论文数据. 西南民族大学学报(人文社会科学版), 2012, 10(3): 229-234.]
[25] Zhou Wei, Huang Zhenfang, Yin Hongwei, et al. Analysis of impact and effect of tourists' perceived value dimensions of a free urban park. Geographical Research, 2012, 31(5): 873-884. [周玮, 黄震方, 殷红卫, 等. 城市公园免费开放对游客感知价值维度的影响及效应分析. 地理研究, 2012, 31(5): 873-884.]
[26] Wang Degen, Chen Tian, Liu Changxue, et al. Analysis on the residents' perception of the impacts of holiday revision on leisure travel in the developed regions. Geographical Research, 2009, 28(5): 1414-1426. [汪德根, 陈田, 刘昌雪, 等.发达地区居民对节假日调整影响休闲旅游的感知分析. 地理研究, 2009, 28(5): 1414-1426.]
[27] Nunally J. Psychometric Theory. 2nd ed. NY: McGrawHill, 1978.
[28] Lu Shaojing, Zhang Jie, Zhang Honglei. A study on the relationship between tourism destination image, tourist satisfaction and behavioral intentions. Human Geography, 2011, 26(4): 121-126. [卢韶婧, 张捷, 张宏磊. 旅游地映象、游客满意度及行为意向关系研究. 人文地理, 2011, 26(4): 121-126.]
[29] Wang Shanhe, Chen Lie. Evalution of city image elements of Guangzhou based on structural equation model. Economic Geography, 2010, 30(1): 69-74. [王山河, 陈烈. 基于结构方程式模型的广州城市形象元素分析评价. 经济地理,2010, 30(1): 69-74.]
[30] Wu Minglong. Structural Equation Model: Operation and Application of AMOS. Chongqing: Chongqing University press, 2009. [吴明隆. 结构方程模型: AMOS的操作与应用. 重庆: 重庆大学出版社, 2009.]
[31] Steiger J H. Structure model evaluation and modification: An interval estimation approach. Multivariate BehavioralResearch, 1990, 25: 173-180.
[32] Li Li, Tang Shuxiang, Wu Xian, et al. Problems and countermeasures in the Chinese evaluation system of scientific and technological achievements. Scientific and Technological Information, 2012(26): 97-98. [李丽, 唐淑香, 伍险峰, 等. 我国科技成果评价制度存在的问题与对策. 科技信息, 2012(26): 97-98.]
[33] Lu Dadao. The value of geographical science and the feelings of geographers. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015, 70(10):1539-1551. [陆大道. 地理科学的价值与地理学者的情怀. 地理学报, 2015, 70(10): 1539-1551.]
[34] Su Qin, Qian Shuwei. Influence relationship and mechanism of tourists' sense of place in world heritage sites. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2012, 67(8): 1137-1148. [苏勤, 钱树伟. 世界遗产地旅游者地方感影响关系及机理分析. 地理学报, 2012, 67(8): 1137-1148.]
[35] Hirsch J E. An index to quantify an individual's scientific research output. The Proceedings of the Hirsch National Academy of Sciences, 2005, 102(46): 16560-16572.
[36] Niu Yu, Wang Degen, Qian Jia. The impact of the published tourism articles in chinese on high citation frequency.Tourism Tribune, 2014, 29(4): 114-124. [牛玉, 汪德根, 钱佳. 基于高被引频次的旅游文献影响力分析. 旅游学刊, 2014, 29(4): 114-124.]
[37] Zhang Jianhe, Ren Changjiang. The analysis of the characteristics of high cited papers in Chinese Journal of Scientificand Technical Periodicals. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodicals, 2011, 22(2): 207-210. [张建合, 任长江.《中国科技期刊研究》高被引论文特征分析. 中国科技期刊研究, 2011, 22(2): 207-210.]
[38] Ye Ying. Cited data of High quality papers and its implications for academic evaluation. Chinese Library Journal, 2010,36(1): 100-103. [叶鹰. 高品质论文被引数据及其对学术评价的启示. 中国图书馆学报, 2010, 36(1): 100-103.]
[39] Han Pengming. Analysis on the academic influence force of the thesis. Information Science, 2010, 28(10): 1505-1508.[韩鹏鸣. 期刊论文的影响力分析. 情报科学, 2010, 28(10): 1505-1508.]