西方人文地理学研究评述与借鉴——面向知行合一的中国人文地理学

doi:10.11821/dlxb201408015

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 中国人文地理学研究需要走出“精致的平庸”,走向“精致的创新”.而要实现这一点,关键是要厘清当前研究中学术与应用间的梗阻,使学术研究回到创新的源点:理论与现实的相互激发,并破除对西方人文地理研究的模仿和迷信.为此,需要借鉴西方人文地理学研究的成果与方法并使之根植于本土的问题和制度;需要完善本土研究机制,包括区分学会和协会、区分学术和应用、区分学术地理和应用地理;要倡导真正的科学精神,对已有研究保持批判性;让知识体系保持高度的开放性,并适应本土知识生产的需求;让研究实事求是、根植于地,在理论与现实之间深度交流.只有这样,中国人文地理学方能实现知行合一,走出殖民地理的陷阱,走上真正自主的知识生产之路.

关键词: 学术与应用, 知行合一, 西方, 中国, 人文地理学

Abstract: The research of China's human geography today calls for a transition from ‘exquisite mediocrity’ to ‘exquisite innovation’. This transition demands scholars to clean up the barriers in- between scholarships and their application, and by returning to the origin of innovation, the interaction between theories and reality, and abandoning their superstition and imitation within the studies or imitation of Western human geography. We identify several key issues for Chinese researchers, such as an understanding of the roots of western theories and methods, and their links to indigenous problems or institutions; improving the development of academic institutions by distinguishing society and association, scholarship and application, academic and applied geography; encouraging real scientific spirit with criticism; keeping the openness of the system of knowledge-production and being respondent to the indigenous demands of the society; deepening the communication between theories and phenomena. To extricate itself from the trap of colonial geography and to build up a model of independent production of knowledge, for China's human geography the combination of knowing and doing is the only pathway.

Key words: combination of knowing and doing, human geography, the West, China, scholarship and application

刘云刚, 李志刚, 黎斌. 西方人文地理学研究评述与借鉴——面向知行合一的中国人文地理学[J]. 地理学报, 2014, 69(8): 1224-1233.

LIU Yungang, LI Zhigang, LI Bin. A critical review of research methods of Western human geography: A combination of knowing and doing for Chinese human geography[J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014, 69(8): 1224-1233.

参考文献

[1] Zhu Dajian. Writing paper needs exquisite innovation. Jiefang Daily, 2013-10-30. [诸大建. 写论文要有精致的创新. 解放日报, 2013-10-30, http://newspaper.jfdaily.com/jfrb/html/2013-10/30/content_1106550.htm. (访问日期: 2014-04-25).]
[2] Wang Shouren. Yu Zili et al. trans. Chuanxilu. Zhengzhou: Zhongzhou Ancient Books Press, 2008: 408. [王守仁. 于自力等校译. 传习录. 郑州: 中州古籍出版社, 2008: 408.]
[3] Johnston R J. Theory and Methodology in Social Geography//Pacione N. Social Geography: Progress and Prospect.London: Croom Helm, 1987: 1-30.
[4] Said E W. Orientalism. London: Penguin Books Limited (UK), 2003: 396. [爱德华·萨义德. 东方学. 北京: 生活·读书·新知三联书店. 2 版. 2007: 528.]
[5] Liu Yungang, Wang Fenglong. Reexamining Chinese human geography: Perspective of theoretical studies in recent thirty years. Human Geography, 2013, 28(1): 14-19. [刘云刚, 王丰龙. 西方主义与实证主义幻象: 近三十年来中国人文地理学理论研究透视. 人文地理, 2013, 28(1): 14-19.]
[6] Stoddart D R. Geography: A European Science. In on Geography and Its History. Oxford: Basil Blackwell, 1986: 28-40.
[7] Morikawa H. Development of Human Geography since 1945: A Comparative Study between English and Germanspeaking Countries. Tokyo: Kokon-shoin, 2004: i-iii. (in Japanese)
[8] Liu Yungang, Xu Xueqiang. Duality of Chinese geography. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2008, 28(5): 587-593. [刘云刚,许学强. 中国地理学的二元结构. 地理科学, 2008, 28(5): 587-593.]
[9] Johnston R J. Institutions and disciplinary fortunes: Two moments in the history of UK geography in the 1960s (I):Geography in the 'plateglass universities. Progress in Human Geography, 2004, 28(1): 57-77.
[10] Johnston R J. Institutions and disciplinary fortunes: two moments in the history of UK geography in the 1960s (II):Human geography and the Social Science Research Council. Progress in Human Geography, 2004, 28(2): 204-226.
[11] Johnston R J. Sixty years of change in human geography. The History of Postwar Social Science Seminars, London School of Economics, 2006-04-25.
[12] Tokyo Geographical Society. Special issue on "Geography in the World" (Part I). Journal of Geography, 2012, 121(4):586-742
[13] Tokyo Geographical Society. Special issue on "Geography in the World" (Part II). Journal of Geography, 2012, 121(5):743-927.
[14] Kobayashi A. People, place, and region: 100 years of human geography in the annals. Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 2010, 100(5): 1095-1106.
[15] Liu Yungang. An introduction to Western geographical publication outside SCI. Human Geography, 2009, 24(5): 31-35. [刘云刚. 地理学期刊与地理学的传统: 西方主要国家地理学期刊评价. 人文地理, 2009, 24(5): 31-35.]
[16] André Meynier. Histoire de la Pensée Geographique en France. Paris: Presses Universitaires de France, 1969. [引自中译本: 安德烈·梅尼埃著. 蔡宗夏译. 法国地理学思想史. 北京: 商务印书馆, 1999: 1-3.]
[17] Hideki Nozawa. The geographical periodical as a mirror of the development of geography. Journal of Geography,1999, 103(6): 663-672.
[18] Association of American Geographers. The geographical dimensions of terrorism: Action Items and Research Priorities [EB/OL]. http://www.aag.org/news/godt.html, Accessed: 2014-03-21.
[19] Harm de Blij. Why Geography Matters: More Than Ever. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005: 4-5.
[20] Johnston, R.J. Geography and Geographers. 4th ed. New York: Edward Arnold. 1991. [中译本: 唐晓峰译. 地理学与地理学家. 北京: 商务印书馆. 1999: 374-408.]
[21] Liu Yungang. The politics of Chinese Geography. Geographical Research, 2013, 32(11): 2170-2175. [刘云刚. 地理学的政治. 地理研究. 2013, 32(11): 2170-2175.]
[22] Fritz Machlup.The Production and Distribution of Knowledge in the United States. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 1973. [引自中译本: 弗里兹·马克卢普著, 孙耀君译. 美国的知识生产与分配. 北京: 中国人民大学出版社,2007: 18.]
[23] John Ziman. Real Science: What It Is and What It Means. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. 2004. [引自中译本: 约翰·齐曼著. 曾国屏译. 真科学. 上海: 上海科技教育出版社, 2002: 17-18, 69-71, 81-83.]
[24] Fan Mingqian. On GLNSST's mode of knowledge production. Journal of Nanjing University of Technology: Social Science Edition, 2008, 7(3): 21-25. [樊旻倩. 对GLNSST 知识生产模式的探究. 南京工业大学学报: 社会科学版,2008, 7(3): 21-25.]
[25] Harvey D. The Condition of Postmodernity: An Enquiry into the Origins of Cultural Change. Hoboken: Wiley.1989. [引自中译本: 戴维·哈维著. 阎嘉译. 后现代的状况: 对文化变迁之缘起的探究. 北京: 商务印书馆, 2003:67, 73, 151, 236, 356, 365.]
[26] Jean-Francois Lyotard. La Condition Postmoderne: Les Editions de Minuit, 1979. [引自中译本: 让-弗朗索瓦·利奥塔尔著. 车槿山译. 后现代状态:关于知识的报告. 南京大学出版社, 2011: 7-8, 46, 98, 102-111.]
[27] Raco M, Imrie R. Governmentality and rights and responsibilities in urban policy. Environment and Planning A, 2000,32(12): 2187-2204.
[28] Deng Zhenglai. Retrospecting and criticizing the apparatus which knowledge is made out of. Journal of SWUPL,2004, 26 (3): 3-6. [邓正来. 知识生产机器的反思与批判: 迈向中国学术规范化讨论的第二阶段. 西南政法大学学报.2004, 26(3): 3-6.]
[29] The Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC), The Royal Geographical Society (with IBG). The Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC): International Benchmarking Review of UK Human Geography.http://www.esrc.ac.uk/_images/Human-Geography-Benchmarking-Review-Report_tcm8-25257.pdf. assessed: 2014-04-25.
[30] Liu Weidong, Cai Yanwei, Zhou Shangyi. Review in Geography (Volume 1). Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2009:181. [刘卫东, 柴彦威, 周尚意. 地理学评论(第一辑). 北京: 商务印书馆, 2009. 181.]
[31] Marx K, Engels F. (translated from German to English by Martin M). Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844.Radford: Foreign Languages Publishing House, 2000. [引自中译本: 马克思著. 刘丕坤译. 1844 年经济学哲学手稿.北京: 人民出版社, 1979: 51-57.]
[32] Chen Yingque. Jinmingguan Cong Gao Er Bian. Shanghai: SDX Joint Publishing Company, 2001: 279. [陈寅恪著. 陈美延编. 金明馆丛稿二编. 上海: 生活·读书·新知三联书店, 2001: 279.]
[33] Zhou Xiaohong. China studies: Possible position and reconstruction of paradigm. Sociological Studies, 2010, (2): 1-29. [周晓虹. 中国研究的可能立场与范式重构. 社会学研究, 2010, (2): 1-29.]
[34] Sun Guodong. The autonomy of Chinese social science. Journal of China Agricultural University: Social Sciences Edition, 2013, 30(2): 17-26. [孙国东. 中国社会科学的自主性: 邓正来先生的终身关怀及其思想与实践. 中国农业大学学报: 社会科学版, 2013, 30(2): 17-26.]
[35] Oriental Morning Post. Lizehou's opinion about thought and knowledge, 2010. http://www.dfdaily.com/html/1170/2010/10/24/529177.shtml. Assessed: 2014-04-25. [东方早报. 李泽厚再谈思想与学问. http://www.dfdaily.com/html/1170/2010/10/24/529177.shtml. 访问日期: 2014-04-25.]
[36] Ai Sixiang: Moving of thought and knowledge. 2010. [爱思想: 思想与学术的位移. 2010. http://www.aisixiang.com/data/34743.html. 访问日期: 2014-04-25.]
[37] Ai Sixiang: Thought in knowledge and knowledge in thought. 2010. [爱思想: 思想中的学术与学术性的思想. http://www.aisixiang.com/data/47710.html. 访问日期: 2014-04-25.]