Ecosystem Services and Ecological Security
ZHANG Rixuan, PENG Jian, XU Zihan, TU Junquan, WANG Jiabin
As an important lens for exploring human-environment interactions in geography, research on cultural ecosystem services (CES) has grown rapidly in recent years, particularly in the interpretation, identification, and quantification of CES. With the rise of internet technologies, scholars have increasingly turned to social media platforms to conduct or support CES studies. This review, based on English-language literature indexed in the Web of Science (WOS) from January 1, 2013 to June 30, 2025, systematically examines the evolving phases of CES research supported by social media data and summarizes the key limitation involved. Social media data offer advantages such as large data volume, easy accessibility, and the ability to capture users' spatial and temporal visitation patterns. However, several limitations remain. At the data level, persistent challenges include representation bias, since social media users are predominantly younger, the perspectives of older demographic groups may be underrepresented. Moreover, the use of web crawlers for data collection raises legitimate concerns regarding user privacy and data protection. At the technical level, unresolved challenges include removing noise and duplicate information, reliably recognizing linguistic and cultural diversity, and addressing the persistent opacity of algorithmic process. At the theoretical level, the research is constrained by the lack of robust frameworks for conceptualizing CES flows and the difficulty in systematically linking user characteristics to specific service demands. In response, this review proposes a developmental framework of "Data foundation-Technical optimization-Theoretical integration". At the data level, the framework suggests improving privacy protocols, conducting cross-platform validation, and encouraging public participation to enhance data robustness. At the technical level, it emphasizes building multilingual training datasets, automating de-noising processes, and improving spatio-temporal resolution to capture dynamic user engagement with green spaces. At the theoretical level, the integration of fine-grained population mobility data from big data science, spatio-temporal insights from geography, public demand analysis from sociology, and policy perspectives from management can help advance the conceptualization of CES flow. This framework connects empirical exploration with theoretical construction, and provides a new pathway for advancing CES research supported by social media data.