中国地学类SCIE收录期刊的学术影响力分析

doi:10.11821/dlxb201411013

Abstract

Abstract:

In order to explore the academic influence of geographical journals in China, this paper selects 17 journals related to Geography in science citation index expanded (SCIE) as research objects. We analyzed the variation of the main citation index including impact factor, total citations, source items, self citation based on JCR database reported by ISI from 2009 to 2013. Furthermore, we analyzed cited frequency of average article, highest citation frequency of single article, proportion of international article using analysis tools on web of science platform. The results show that: (1) generally, the impact factor showed an upward trend and there was a slight increase of academic impact of these journals during the five years. (2) J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA, SCI CHINA EARTH SCI, ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL, ADV ATMOS SCI, PEDOSPHERE are the top five in the overall impact factor rankings, which are in line with the actual situation of China. (3) Most of the geographical journals had a low proportion of international articles, indicating the low level of internationalization. (4) The other citation indexes including impact factor, total citations, cited frequency of average article, highest citation frequency of single article keep low within the same subject category. Factors that affect academic influence of geographical journals were discussed, and some suggestions were put forward to promote the academic influence. On one hand, the journals should focus on high quality articles and knowledge innovation so as to improve the academic quality of journals based on a larger global scale; on the other hand, the sources of manuscripts, editing and distributing should be standardized to a higher international level.

Key words: geographical journals, academic influence, JCR, Web of Science

Chunli ZHANG, Chunlei SHENG, Sixiu NI. Academic influence of China's geographical journals in SCIE[J].Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014, 69(11): 1725-1733.

Figures/Tables 8

Tab. 1

Statistics of China′s geographical journals in SCIE

序号	英文刊名 (缩写)	中文刊名	刊期	创刊年	主办单位
1	Science China-Earth Sciences (SCI CHINA EARTH SCI)	中国科学：地球科学 (英文版)	月刊	1950	中国科学院;国家自然科学基金委员会
2	Journal of Geographical Sciences (J GEOGR SCI)	地理学报 (英文版)	双月刊	1990	中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所;中国地理学会
3	Chinese Geographical Science (CHINESE GEOGR SCI)	中国地理科学 (英文版)	双月刊	1991	中国科学院东北地理与农业生态研究所
4	Journal of Earth Science (J EARTH SCI-CHINA)	地球科学学刊 (英文版)	双月刊	1990	中国地质大学
5	Frontiers of Earth Science (FRONT EARTH SCI-PRC)	地球科学前沿 (英文版)	季刊	2007	高等教育出版社
6	Journal of Arid Land (J ARID LAND)	干旱区科学 (英文版)	双月刊	2009	中国科学院新疆生态与地理研究所;科学出版社
7	Journal of Mountain Science (J MT SCI-ENGL)	山地科学学报 (英文版)	双月刊	2004	中国科学院成都山地灾害与环境研究所
8	Acta Oceanologica Sinica (ACTA OCEANOL SIN)	海洋学报 (英文版)	双月刊	1982	中国海洋学会
9	Journal of Tropical Meteorology (J TROP METEOROL)	热带气象学报 (英文版)	季刊	1995	中国气象局广州热带海洋气象研究所
10	Chinese Journal of Oceanology and Limnology (CHIN J OCEANOL LIMN)	中国海洋湖沼学报 (英文版)	季刊	1982	中国海洋湖沼学会;中国科学院海洋研究所
11	International Journal of Sediment Research (INT J SEDIMENT RES)	国际泥沙研究 (英文版)	季刊	1986	国际泥沙研究培训中心
12	PEDOSPHERE (PEDOSPHERE)	土壤圈 (英文版)	双月刊	1991	中国土壤学会、中科院南京土壤研究所和土壤与农业可持续发展国家重点实验室
13	Advances in Atmospheric Sciences (ADV ATMOS SCI)	大气科学进展 (英文版)	双月刊	1984	中国科学院大气物理研究所
14	Acta Meteorologica Sinica (ACTA METEOROL SIN)	气象学报 (英文版)	双月刊	1987	中国气象学会主办
15	Frontiers of Environmental Science & Engineering (FRONT ENV SCI ENG)	环境科学与工程学前沿 (英文版)	双月刊	2007	清华大学和高等教育出版社联合主办
16	Journal of Environmental Sciences-China (J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA)	环境科学学报 (英文版)	月刊	1989	中国科学院生态环境研究中心
17	Acta Geologica Sinica-English Edition (ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL)	地质学报 (英文版)	双月刊	1922	中国地质学会

Tab. 1

Tab. 2

Fig. 1

Tab. 3

Tab. 4

Tab. 5

Tab. 6

Fig. 2

References 14

[1]	Zhao Xin, Yao Lufeng, He Shujin.Development of geographical journals in China during 1978-2008. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2009, 64(3): 381-384.
	[赵歆, 姚鲁烽, 何书金. 近30年来中国地理学及相关学科期刊的发展. 地理学报, 2009, 64(3): 381-384.]
[2]	Sun Qun, Wang Haiying, Wang Wenhu et al. Comparison and analysis on average citation rate of Chinese and foreign journals. Acta Editologica, 1999, 11(4): 214-216.
	[孙群, 汪海英, 王文瑚等. 中外地学期刊平均引文率对比与分析.编辑学报, 1999, 11(4): 214-216.]
[3]	He Xuefeng, Peng Chaoqun.Dynamic evaluation model of academic influence of sci-tech periodicals. Acta Editologica, 2002, 14(4): 238-240.
	[何学锋, 彭超群. 科技期刊学术影响力的动态评估模型. 编辑学报, 2002, 14(4): 238-240.]
[4]	Web of Science database.
	[Web of Science 数据库.]
[5]	2009-2013 Journal Citation Reports (JCR).
	[2012年度期刊引证报告.]
[6]	Institute for Scientific Information, 1998. Journal Citation Reports: A Bibliometric Analysis of Science Journals in the ISI Database. Philadelphia: Institute for Scientific Information Inc., 1999
[7]	Ren Shengli, Wang Baoqing, Guo Zhiming et al. Impact factor should be used cautiously in evaluating scientific research. Chinese Science Bulletin, 2000, 45(2): 218-222.
	[任胜利, 王宝庆, 郭志明等. 应慎重使用期刊的影响因子评价科研成果. 科学通报, 2000, 45(2): 218-222.]
[8]	Archambault E, Lariviere V.History of the journal impact factor: Contingencies and consequences. Scientometrics, 2009, 79(3): 635-649
[9]	Guo Jianshun, Zhang Xuedong, Li Wenhong et al. High self citation rate of Chinese scientific journals and unreasonable self citation screening. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodical, 2010, 21(4): 455-458.
	[郭建顺, 张学东, 李文红等. 我国科技期刊的高自引率及其不合理自引的甄别. 中国科技期刊研究, 2010, 21(4): 455-458.]
[10]	Hua Fang, Feng Yulin.Quantitative research of journal internationalization degree. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodical, 2013, 24(6): 1104-1108.
	[花芳, 冯玉林. 期刊国际化程度的量化指标研究. 中国科技期刊研究, 2013, 24(6): 1104-1108.]
[11]	Yang Caixia.Citation analysis of "Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodical" from 1998 to 2007. Chinese Journal of Scientific and Technical Periodical, 2009, 20(1): 77-81.
	[杨彩霞. 《中国科技期刊研究》1998-2007年论文被引分析. 中国科技期刊研究, 2009, 20(1): 77-81.]
[12]	Zhong Chen, Wang Feifei.Influence analysis of library and information science journals based on JCR. Information Science, 2012, 30(11): 1720-1754.
	[钟晨, 王菲菲. 基于JCR指标的图书情报领域期刊影响力分析. 情报科学, 2012, 30(11): 1720-1754.]
[13]	Fan Guangbing.The discipline distribution characteristics of geography journals (English edition) in China. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2013, 68(9): 1292-1297.
	[范广兵. 中国地理学英文版期刊的学科分布特征. 地理学报, 2013, 68(9): 1292-1297.]
[14]	Sun Yuling, Chen Chaohui.Academic influence of Chinese biology science journals in SCIE based on JCR. Journal of Information, 2007, 26(6): 135-141.
	[孙玉玲, 陈朝晖. SCIE收录中国生物类期刊学术影响力分析: 基于JCR的研究. 情报杂志, 2007, 26(6): 135-141.]

序号	刊名	2009年	2010年	2011年	2012年	2013年	IF5
1	SCI CHINA EARTH SCI	0.880	1.271	1.588(0.699)*	1.255	1.340	1.548
2	J GEOGR SCI	0.518	0.673	0.832	0.907	1.123	1.411
3	CHINESE GEOGR SCI	0.426	0.656	0.5	0.5	0.727	0.786
4	J EARTH SCI-CHINA	-	0.286	0.312	0.395	0.546	0.622
5	FRONT EARTH SCI-PRC	-	-	-	0.081	0.516
6	J ARID LAND	-	-	0.542	0.453	0.793	1.015
7	J MT SCI-ENGL	0.4	0.632	1	0.664	0.763	1.086
8	ACTA OCEANOL SIN	0.481	0.476	0.494	0.583	0.684	0.762
9	J TROP METEOROL	-	0.38	0.313	0.255	0.266	0.476
10	CHIN J OCEANOL LIMN	-	0.325	0.498	0.577	0.684	0.715
11	INT J SEDIMENT RES	0.908	1.708	1.082	0.718	0.977	1.26
12	PEDOSPHERE	1.103	0.978	1.161	1.232	1.379	1.735
13	ADV ATMOS SCI	0.691	0.925	0.987	1.338	1.459	1.411
14	ACTA METEOROL SIN	0.874	0.704	0.534	0.799	1.111	1.301
15	FRONT ENV SCI ENG	-	-	0.754	0.886	0.881
16	J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA	1.412	1.513	1.660	1.773	1.922	2.465
17	ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL	1.172	1.408	1.250	1.568	1.406	1.403

序号	刊名	2009年	2010年	2011年	2012年	2013年	合计
1	SCI CHINA EARTH SCI	2032	2634(40)	180	524	976	6386
2	J GEOGR SCI	157	276	366	483	789	2071
3	CHINESE GEOGR SCI	125	163	207	295	428	1218
4	J EARTH SCI-CHINA	34	33	87	179	272	605
5	FRONT EARTH SCI-PRC	-	-	-	12	61	73
6	J ARID LAND	-	-	28	65	143	236
7	J MT SCI-ENGL	133	186	275	328	504	1426
8	ACTA OCEANOL SIN	629	675	627	747	868	3546
9	J TROP METEOROL	-	232	298	255	293	1078
10	CHIN J OCEANOL LIMN	-	331	447	553	720	2051
11	INT J SEDIMENT RES	173	271	275	322	381	1422
12	PEDOSPHERE	635	819	932	1142	1411	4939
13	ADV ATMOS SCI	899	1028	1236	1600	1912	6675
14	ACTA METEOROL SIN	678	694	793	882	1042	4089
15	FRONT ENV SCI ENG	-	-	149	255	384	788
16	J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA	1438	1951	2771	3819	4774	14753
17	ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL	1382	1563	1683	2030	2358	9016

序号	刊名	2009年	2010年	2011年	2012年	2013年	合计
1	SCI CHINA EARTH SCI	221	182	184	195	198	980
2	J GEOGR SCI	62	69	82	81	79	373
3	CHINESE GEOGR SCI	47	69	73	66	64	319
4	J EARTH SCI-CHINA	84	182	76	87	90	519
5	FRONT EARTH SCI-PRC	61	51	49	46	48	255
6	J ARID LAND	10	39	37	50	51	187
7	J MT SCI-ENGL	43	39	92	85	102	361
8	ACTA OCEANOL SIN	69	82	86	91	138	466
9	J TROP METEOROL	31	52	50	56	40	229
10	CHIN J OCEANOL LIMN	133	174	152	123	145	727
11	INT J SEDIMENT RES	37	36	42	46	52	213
12	PEDOSPHERE	88	86	91	86	88	439
13	ADV ATMOS SCI	116	119	121	108	134	598
14	ACTA METEOROL SIN	63	57	56	60	69	305
15	FRONT ENV SCI ENG	59	58	67	101	95	380
16	J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA	267	283	282	281	297	1410
17	ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL	120	132	133	134	132	651

序号	刊名	2009年	2010年	2011年	2012年	2013年
		S (%)	IF^-	S (%)	IF^-	S (%)	IF^-	S (%)	IF^-	S (%)	IF^-
1	SCI CHINA EARTH SCI	11	0.718	0	1.271	0(10)	1.588 (0.622)	9	1.134	6	1.256
2	J GEOGR SCI	15	0.435	22	0.519	19	0.672	19	0.728	12	0.982
3	CHINESE GEOGR SCI	25	0.317	15	0.552	31	0.345	19	0.401	11	0.64
4	J EARTH SCI-CHINA	-	-	12	0.25	6	0.293	16	0.329	17	0.448
5	FRONT EARTH SCI-PRC	-	-	-	-	-	-	0	0.081	14	0.442
6	J ARID LAND	-	-	-	-	84	0.083	32	0.307	14	0.678
7	J MT SCI-ENGL	8	0.367	14	0.539	43	0.561	14	0.565	25	0.571
8	ACTA OCEANOL SIN	20	0.384	20	0.376	13	0.427	12	0.512	19	0.554
9	J TROP METEOROL	-	-	51	0.183	19	0.253	15	0.216	0	0.226
10	CHIN J OCEANOL LIMN	-	-	14	0.277	13	0.43	9	0.521	7	0.629
11	INT J SEDIMENT RES	66	0.308	66	0.569	68	0.342	44	0.397	20	0.773
12	PEDOSPHERE	3	1.059	4	0.938	10	1.034	8	1.13	4	1.316
13	ADV ATMOS SCI	22	0.537	22	0.712	27	0.719	25	0.996	19	1.179
14	ACTA METEOROL SIN	15	0.736	19	0.565	14	0.458	10	0.716	18	0.905
15	FRONT ENV SCI ENG	-	-	-	-	8	0.693	6	0.829	12	0.774
16	J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA	7	1.306	7	1.395	7	1.533	6	1.65	10	1.726
17	ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL	35	0.758	44	0.777	52	0.595	37	0.985	50	0.699

序号	刊名	国际稿源比 (%)	国际合作论文比 (%)	纯中国稿源比例 (%)	篇均被引频次	单篇被引最高频次
1	SCI CHINA EARTH SCI	1.79	14.40	83.81	2.93	69
2	J GEOGR SCI	5.33	12.27	82.40	2.91	51
3	CHINESE GEOGR SCI	2.82	16.62	80.56	1.74	20
4	J EARTH SCI-CHINA	21.47	13.15	65.38	1.63	20
5	FRONT EARTH SCI-PRC	35.90	13.33	50.77	1.18	9
6	J ARID LAND	18.72	18.17	63.11	1.53	16
7	J MT SCI-ENGL	36.44	13.15	50.41	1.55	12
8	ACTA OCEANOL SIN	6.25	11.25	82.50	1.02	10
9	J TROP METEOROL	1.31	8.34	90.38	0.38	6
10	CHIN J OCEANOL LIMN	5.57	10.06	84.37	1.61	16
11	INT J SEDIMENT RES	63.13	8.76	28.11	2.91	23
12	PEDOSPHERE	33.26	18.10	48.64	3.98	59
13	ADV ATMOS SCI	13.84	19.11	67.05	3.54	51
14	ACTA METEOROL SIN	2.13	9.12	88.75	1.16	21
15	FRONT ENV SCI ENG	10.50	12.50	77.00	1.18	16
16	J ENVIRON SCI-CHINA	24.70	9.60	65.70	5.22	41
17	ACTA GEOL SIN-ENGL	18.42	10.85	70.73	2.92	27
	均值	17.74	12.87	69.39	2.20	27

Academic influence of China's geographical journals in SCIE

RichHTML

PDF (PC)

Like

Knowledge

Cited

Abstract

Cite this article

share this article

Figures/Tables 8

References 14

Related Articles 5

Metrics

Comments

[1]	Xin ZHAO. Main characteristics of geography journals indexed in SCI [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2015, 70(9): 1526-1534.
[2]	DONG Liuqun, SHI Zhenghong. A statistical analysis of the papers published in Acta Geographica Sinica during 1934-2013 [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014, 69(9): 1385-1390.
[3]	Xiaoling LI. Comparison of the mainstream geographical journals between the West and China [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2014, 69(7): 1025-1038.
[4]	FAN Guangbing. The discipline distribution characteristics of geography journals (English edition) in China [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2013, 68(9): 1292-1297.
[5]	WANG Xian-wen, LIU Ze-yuan, LUAN Chun-juan, LIANG Yong-xia. Analysis of SSCI Human Geography Journals [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2009, 64(2): 243-252.